Winning Years

2021
2020

Our Products

2021

Fishers Island Lemonade

Other Spirits
91 Points

Fishers Pink Lemonade

Other Spirits
90 Points

Fishers Spiked Tea

Other Spirits
82 Points

Fishers Fizz

Other Spirits
81 Points

Fishers Spirit Pop

Other Spirits
80 Points

Fishers Island Lemonade

Other Spirits

View Certificate Shelf Talkers

USA Spirits Ratings 2021

Gold Medal

91 Points

Tasting Notes:

Slight sweetness that lingers on the nose. Sweet and tart citrus tones layered with sweet candied lemon flavors.

Producer Name: Fishers Island Lemonade
Country: United States
Vintage: N/A

Category: Other Spirits

TASTED BY:

Megan Quinlan

Judges are active U.S. off-premise trade buyers and evaluated this product in 2026.

Fishers Pink Lemonade

Other Spirits

View Certificate Shelf Talkers

USA Spirits Ratings 2021

Gold Medal

90 Points

Tasting Notes:

Pleasant citrus nose driven by lemon peel and lime zest. The sweetness overwhelms the palate with hints of tart lemon to balance it out.

Producer Name: Fishers Island Lemonade
Country: United States
Vintage: N/A

Category: Other Spirits

TASTED BY:

Megan Quinlan

Judges are active U.S. off-premise trade buyers and evaluated this product in 2026.

Fishers Spiked Tea

Other Spirits

View Certificate Shelf Talkers

USA Spirits Ratings 2021

Silver Medal

82 Points

Tasting Notes:

Flavors of tea and bright lemons. The palate is sweet, sour and refreshing.

Producer Name: Fishers Island Lemonade
Country: United States
Vintage: N/A

Category: Other Spirits

TASTED BY:

Dan O'brien

Adam `Boots` Brogan

Bar Manager at Louie’s Bar, San Francisco, California. Owner of The Bootsy Company

Judges are active U.S. off-premise trade buyers and evaluated this product in 2026.

Fishers Fizz

Other Spirits

View Certificate Shelf Talkers

USA Spirits Ratings 2021

Silver Medal

81 Points

Tasting Notes:

Nuances of powdered lemon, with an artificial citrus nose. A dry palate with simple citrus notes.

Producer Name: Fishers Island Lemonade
Country: United States
Vintage: N/A

Category: Other Spirits

TASTED BY:

Judges are active U.S. off-premise trade buyers and evaluated this product in 2026.

Fishers Spirit Pop

Other Spirits

View Certificate Shelf Talkers

USA Spirits Ratings 2021

Silver Medal

80 Points

Tasting Notes:

Nuances of ripe lemon and sweet honey. The palate is sweet and tart with lingering hints of ripe candied lemon and sweet fresh honeycomb.

Producer Name: Fishers Island Lemonade
Country: United States
Vintage: N/A

Category: Other Spirits

TASTED BY:

Otello Tiano

Judges are active U.S. off-premise trade buyers and evaluated this product in 2026.

Winning Years

2021

2020

Fishers Island Lemonade

Fishers Pink Lemonade

Fishers Spiked Tea

Fishers Fizz

Fishers Spirit Pop

Tasting Notes:

TASTED BY:

Megan Quinlan

Tasting Notes:

TASTED BY:

Megan Quinlan

Tasting Notes:

TASTED BY:

Dan O'brien

Adam `Boots` Brogan

Tasting Notes:

TASTED BY:

Tasting Notes:

TASTED BY:

Otello Tiano

Follow Us:

Contact Information: